EM 2013
As to questions posed at the beginning of this methodological assessment: Are the chapters in correct order? Do they create a complete entity? Are they properly constructed? The answers should be positive ones. In terms of the research topic, Fr. Pakuła’s dissertation presents a valuable work, but an attentive analysis of its contents indicates that there are no perfect works, which is probably as well. I will relate to only one issue: Fr. Papczyński used interchangeably the terms “imitating” and “following,” which the dissertation author indicates, but does not address critically. Many present-day theologians also use these terms interchangeably. However, considering modern psychology, it is important to note that the term “imitating” signifies the formation of mature personality traits, while the term “following” describes the formation of appropriate attitudes. If in Fr. Papczyński’s works the verb “imitare” (to imitate) can also refer to the “following” of the saints, especially the Blessed Virgin Mary, the verb “sequire” (to follow) refers in principle to following Christ. Therefore, it would be necessary to make more precise Fr. Pakuła’s assertion that in Fr. Papczyński’s teaching “sequela Christi” leads to the re-creation of the Master’s life in the attitude of His disciple. If we are to understand the re-creation as an imitation, then the disciple wouldn’t be able to duplicate the life of his Master, but he could introduce into his life his Master’s manner of living. This dissertation proves that the undertaken research yielded many valuable fruits. Its author depicts for the first time a comprehensive image of religious spirituality of the first religious congregation founded on Polish soil. His task was difficult because ideas and concepts concerned with this topic were scattered throughout Fr. Papczyński’s works and the documents of the early Marian tradition. The present work accentuates the Marian character of the newly created Congregation, although Fr. Pakuła indicates that the Founder did not leave behind any explanation as to his choice of the immaculistic character for the community he founded. Also noteworthy is Fr. Pakuła’s critical approach to both Fr. Papczyński’s writings and the works produced by the researchers of religious spirituality, i.e., his polemics with the known historian of spirituality Karol Górski, who claims that the Marian Founder favored external asceticism, while Fr. Pakuła asserts that he favored an internal austerity and self-denial. The Fr. Ireneusz Werbiński 588
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjI2Mw==